Some of you have requested information regarding my experiences with The Sampler and Poppytalk Handmade. Before I decided to participate in both of these, I also searched for information online and couldn't find much info about individual sellers' experiences. So here are mine:
The Sampler: I donated 50 sets of gift tags and paper swatches to the Boston Sampler in February.
What I thought would happen: I thought these samplers would end up in the hands of local storeowners, media and consumers and that I would be contacted by locals who had received a box who wanted to learn more about my work.
What actually happened: For the most part, nothing. I never received any inquiries from media, storeowners, or consumers. I did get one Etsy order earlier this week where the buyer wrote in the "message to buyer" that she had received a Sampler and liked my work. So I can attribute that one sale directly to the Sampler.
Would I do it again: Yes, but only with certain conditions. I believe the Sampler has a special press-only box that they send out only to media contacts. I would consider participating in one of these boxes. I think the Sampler is a great concept and by participating I was able to get my work out there to potential customers who may not have found out about me otherwise. But I'm not sure that the Sampler customer necessarily is a rifferaff customer.
Poppytalk Handmade Market: I paid a $60 fee to participate in the online market for a month. I uploaded 12 images of my work with links to my Etsy listings.
What I thought would happen: I expected to get a big boost of sales/inquiries on the first day and I wanted to establish an identity as a "green" designer by participating in the "Green Pop" market, the theme for the month.
What actually happened: No boost in sales. I think I got a few extra "hearts" for my Etsy shop, meaning that people stopped by to visit and liked what they saw and "hearted" my store. This month Jan started showcasing studio tours of the participating artists, so by submitting some pics and answering the interview questions, my shop got some airtime on the Poppytalk blog front page.
Would I do it again: Hmmm. Not sure. It's hard to tell where your Etsy buyers come from if they don't explicitly tell you themselves. I don't think I made back my $60 over the course of the month from Poppytalk buyers. As always, my Etsy sales seem to be directly related to how often I list new stuff. I think this is a guaranteed route to consistent sales, but I can't say the same for PHM. I do think I got great visibility and by corresponding with Jan, the writer of the blog, I now feel like I have a good relationship with this blog, which I consider a trendsetter. In the future, I think Jan will recognize my work and post any updates I'd send her. Also she did choose one of my images to use for the PHM ad on Design Sponge, adding to my product visibility. The perks here were a little more subtle. I think it was great for my overall goal of establishing an identity and a presence but did not result in direct sales.
I hope this recap can help some of you with your decision to participate in marketing opportunities like this. Neither one required an exceptional amount of time and money so it was all worth it. Anyone care to chime in with their own experiences in the comments section?